Historical Perspective&Historiography

Current Issue

By Issue

By Author

By Subject

Author Index

Keyword Index

About Journal

Aims and Scope

Editorial Board

office

Publication Ethics

Indexing and Abstracting

Related Links

FAQ

Peer Review Process

Journal Metrics

News

Registration guide in the system

Article submission guide

Guide for Author

Transcription of resources

Pablons Registration Guide

Arbitration process

Judges of the Journal of Historical Perspective & Historiography in 2023

Judges of the Journal of Historical Perspective & Historiography in 20221

Judges of the Journal of Historical Perspective & Historiography in 2021

Reviewers in 2020

Reviewers in 2019

Explaining ʿAbbās Zaryāb Khoii’s Historiography Components

Document Type : Scientific-Research

Authors

1 PhD student in Islamic History, University of Isfahan, Isfahan. Iran

2 Professor in History, University of Isfahan, Isfahan. Iran

3 Professor, Department of History, University of Isfahan,, Isfahan. Iran

4 Associate Professor of history department, TMU. Tehran.Iran

Abstract

In the new centuries, human beings' intellectual progress and the insightful and methodical developments of various sciences also made the thinkers in history redefine this knowledge's identity and science. These developments began in the West. After many challenges and the creation of new historiography schools, it led to establishing the science of history's prestige and position among other sciences. Iranian historians did not shy away from these developments. So, Iranian historians sought to transfer new ideas by putting contemporary Iranian historiography in the transition from a traditional to a modern mode. One of these historians in academic circles is ʿAbbās Zaryāb Khoii, among whose historical works see scientific historiography signs. The present study mainly aims to critique Zaryāb Khoii's methodological historiography and explain his historiography's components by providing clear and precise examples. It seems that this historian has taken reasonable steps in applying the principles of scientific historiography in his works and, with a combination of scientific, intellectual, and critical approaches, seeks to provide a new explanation of some historical narratives and traditional views. Among Zaryāb Khoii's historiography components are the rigorous modification of narratives, the critique of Orientalists' essential history, the neutrality of historical analysis as much as possible, using other sciences' achievements, and the attempt to present a multifaceted picture of historical phenomena. Of course, in some cases, he still has not gone beyond the scope of traditional descriptive historiography. Hence, perhaps, he can be described as a neoclassical historian.

Keywords

References
List of sources with English handwriting
Persian and Arabic Sources
-       Aḥmadī, Bābak (1387 Š.), Risālaīī dar Tārīḵ, Tehran: Markaz. [In Persian]
-       Āqāĵarī, Sayyed Hāšim; et. al (1393Š.), “Raviš-e Asnādī va Goẕār az Ān dar Tarīḵnigārī Eslāmī”, Faṣlnāma-e Tārīḵnigārī va Tārīknegarī, No. 98. [In Persian]
-       Āqāĵarī, Sayyed Hāšim (1396 s.), Ĵozva-ye Dar-e Tārīḵnigārī, Tehran: Dānišgāh-e Tarbīat Modaris. [In Persian]
-       Āīīnavand, Ṣādiq (1387 Š.), ‘Elm-e Tārīḵ dar Gostara-ye Ĵahān-e Eslām, Tehran: Pežūhišgāh-e ‘Olūm-e Ensānī va Moṭāli ‘āt-e Farhangī. [In Persian]
-       Āštīānī, Manūčihr (1396 Š.), Ĵāma‘ešināsī-e Tārīḵī, Tehran: Pežūhišgāh-e ‘Olūm-e Ensānī va Moṭāli ‘āt-e Farhangī. [In Persian]
-       ‘Avād al-Ma‘rūf, Bašār (1385), “Maẓāhir al-Taṯīr ‘Elm al-Ḥadīṯ ‘End al-Moslemīn”, Al-Aqlām, 1, No. 5.
-       ‘Avād al-Ma‘rūf, Bašār (1386), “Aṯar al-Ḥadīt fi Našāh al-Tārīḵ ‘End al-Moslemīn”, Al-Aqlām, 2, No. 9.
-       Dehbāšī, ‘Alī (1393 Š.) “Yādnāma-ye ‘Abbās Zaryāb ḵoīī”, Boḵārā, Np. 104. [In Persian]
-       Al- Dorī, ‘Abd al- ‘Azīz (1426), Nišā ‘Elm al- Tārīḵ ‘end al-‘Arab, Beirut: MArkaz Dirāsāt al-‘Arabīyya.
-       EM (1391), Vol. 2.
-       Esmāīl, Maḥmūd (2005), Eškālīyyat al-Minhaĵ fi Dirāsat al- Torāṯ, Royat lil Našr va al-Tawzī‘.
-       Esmā‘īlī, Ḥabīballāh; et. al (1392 Š.), Ĵostārḥaīī dar Tārīḵ va Tārīknigārī, Tehran: ḵāna Ketāb. [In Persian]
-       Faṣīhī, Sīmīn (1388 Š.), “Az Tārīk-e Mardān-e Noḵba tā Tārīḵ-e Zanān Farāmūš šoda”, Maĵala-ye Tārīḵnigārī va Tārīḵnegarī, No. 2. [In Persian]
-       Faṣīhī, Sīmīn (1390 Š.), “Nisbathā-ye Tārīḵ va Īdeoložī”, Maĵala-ye Māh Tārīḵ va Ĵoḡrāfīā, No. 164. [In Persian]
-       Fūlādvand, ‘Ezzatallāh (1381 Š.), “ḵodā va Ensān dar Tārīḵ”, Boḵārā, No. 25, 26.
-       “Ḥadīṯ” (1387 Š.), EWI, Vol. 12. [In Persian]
-       “Ḥadīṯ” (1391 Š.), GIE, Vol. 20. [In Persian]
-       Ḥażratī, Ḥasan (1393 Š.), Raviš-e Pežūhiš dar Tārīḵšinasī, Tehran: Pežūhiškada Emām ḵomaīnī va Enqilāb-e Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Ḥażratī, Ḥasan (1381 Š.), Ta‘amolātī dar ‘Elm-e Tārīḵ va Tārīḵnigārī-e Eslāmī, Tehran: Naqš-e Ĵahān. [In Persian]
-       Black, Jeremy; et. al (1389 Š.), Motāli‘a-ye Tārīḵ, translated by Moḥammad ‘Alī Īmānpūr, Mashhad: Ferdowsi university of Mashhad. [In Persian]
-       ḵiżr, ‘Abd al-‘Alīm (1995), Al-Moslimūn va Ketāba al-Tārīḵ Dirāsa fi al-Taṣīl al- Eslāmī l‘elm al-Tārīḵ, Al-Mahd al-‘Ālamī lil fikr al-Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Mīrĵafarī, Mortażā; et. al (1388 Š.), Raviš-e Pežūhiš dar Tārīḵ, Tehran: Pežūhišgāh-e Farhang va Andīša Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Mīrzā Ṣāliḥ, Ḡolām Ḥosayn (1381 Š.), Tārīḵ, Naẓarīa-e Tārīḵ va Tārīḵnigārī (Goftogū bā ‘Abbās Zaryāb), Tehran: Farzān-e Rūz. [In Persian] [In Persian]
-       Moftaḵarī, Ḥosayn (1390 Š.), Mabānī-e ‘Elm-e Tārīḵ, Tehran: SAMT.
-       Moṣṭafā Šākir (1978), Al-Tārīḵ al-‘Arabī va al-Movariḵūn, Beirut: Dār al-‘Elm lil Molāīīn.
-       Mollāīī Tavānī, ‘Alī Reżā (1395 Š.), Darāmadī bar Raviš-e Pežūhiš dar Tārīḵ, Tehran: Nai. [In Persian]
-       Pākatčī, Aḥmad (1392 Š.), Fiqh al-Ḥadīṯ, Tehran: Entišārāt-e Dānišgāh-e Emām Ṣādiq. [In Persian]
-       Pākatčī, Aḥmad (1392 Š.), Raviššināsī-e Tārīḵ, Tehran: Entišārāt-e Dānišgāh-e Emām Ṣādiq. [In Persian]
-       Pežuhišgarān-e Mo‘āṣir-e Īrān, Vol. 10, Tehran: Farhang-e Mo‘āṣir. [In Persian]
-       Rādmaniš, ‘Ezzatallāh (1379 š.), Maktabhā-ye Tārīḵī va Taĵadodgarāīī-e Tārīḵ, Tehran: Payk-e Dāniš. [In Persian]
-       Rażavī, Sayyed Abulfażl (1391 Š.), Darāmadī bar Tārīḵnigārī Īrānī Eslāmī, Tehran: Pežūhišgāh-e Farhang va Andīša Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Rażavī, Sayyed Abulfażl (13 94 Š.), Falsafa-ye Entiqādī-e Tārīḵ, Tehran: Pežūhišgāh-e Farhang va Andīša Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Sālim, Sayyed ‘Abd al- ‘Azīz (1961), Al-Tārīḵ va al- Movariḵūn al- ‘Arab, Beirut: Dā al- Nihżat al-‘Arabīyya.
-       Saĵĵādī, Sayyed Ṣādiq (1386 Š.), Tārīḵnigārī dar Eslām, Tehran: SAMT. [In Persian]
-       Saḵāvī, Moḥammad b. ‘Abd al-Raḥmān (1413), Al- A ‘alān bil Tawbīḵ liman ẕam al- Tārīk, Beirut: Dār al- Ĵīl.
-       Ṭāhirī, Farhād (1381 Š.), “Sahm-e Ostād Zaryāb dar Nihżat-e Dāerat al-Ma‘ārifnevīsī- e Mo‘āsir”, Maĵala-e Ma‘ārif, No. 57. [In Persian]
-       Yāsamī, Rašīd (1392 Š.), Āīīn-e Nigāriš-e Tārīḵ, Tehran: Asāṭīr. [In Persian]
-       Zarrīnkūb, ‘Abd al-Hosyan (1389 š.0, Tārīḵ dar Tarāzū, Tehran: Amīr Kabīr. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, Ābbās; Mašāyiḵ Farīdanī, Moḥammad Ḥosayn (1371 Š.), “Emām”, ES, Vol. 2. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1368 Š.), Bazm Āvard, Tehran: ‘Elmī va Soḵan. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1385 Š.), Bazm Āvardī Dīgar, Tehran: Markaz-e Dāerat al-Ma‘ārif-e Bozorg-e Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1381 Š.), “Dar Bāb-e Tārīḵ-e Eslām va Sīra-ye Nabavī”, Maĵala-ye Ma‘ārif, No. 57. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1387 Š.), Darsgoftārhā-ye Falsafa-ye Tārīḵ, edited by Hosayn Tavakollī et. al, Tehran: Ṭarḥ va Našr-e Hāmūn. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1354 Š.), Maĵala-ye Talāš. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (n. d.), Movariḵān-e Īrānī dar ‘Ahd-e Eslāmī. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1385 Š.), Sīra-ye Rasūlallāh az Āḡāz tā Hiĵrat, Tehran: Sorūš. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1387 Š.), Šaṭ Šīrīn-e Poršokat, edited by Mīlād ‘Aẓīmī, Tehran: Morvārīd. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (n. d.), Tārīḵ-e Sāsānīān, Tehran: Entišārāt-e Dānišgāh-e Āzād-e Īrān. [In Persian]
-       Zaryāb ḵoīī, ‘Abbās (1350 Š.), Tārīḵ-e Šāhašāhī-e Do Hizār va Pānṣad Sāla-ye Īrān, Edāra-ye Koll-e Nigāriš-e Vizārat-e Farhang va Honar. [In Persian]
 
 
English, German and French Sources
-       Bailyn, Bernard (1994), On the Teaching and Writing of History: Responses to a Series of Questions, Montgomery.
-       Brundage, Anthony (2017), Going to the Sources: A Guide to Historical Research and Writing, Wiley-Blackwell.
-       Burke, Peter (2005), History and Social Theory, Cornell University Press.
-       Carr, Edward Hallet (1967), What is History? Vintage.
-       Collingwood, Robin George (2014), The Idea of History, Martino Fine Books.
-       Gibb, Hamilton Alexander Rosskeen (1968), Arabische Literaturgeschichte, Zurich: Artemis.
-       Humphreys, R. Stephen (1991), Islamic History: A Framework for Inquiry, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
-       Hughes-Warrington, Marine (2008), Fifty Key Thinkers on History, Routledge.
-       Iggres, George G. (2005), Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge, Wesleyan University Press.
-       Jaspers, Karl (1949), Vom Ursprung und Ziel der Geschichte, Artemis-Verlag.
-       McCullagh, Behan (2004), The Logic of History: Putting Postmodernism in Perspective, Routledge.
-       Munslow, Alun (2006), Deconstructing History, Routledge.
-       Myrdal, Gunar (1969), Objectivity in Social Research, Pantheon.
-       Noldeke, Theodor (1879), Geschichte der Perser und Araber zur zeit Sasaniden, Gottingen: Dieterichs’che.
-       Robinson, Chase F. (2002), Islamic Historiography, Chambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-       Rosenthal, Franz (1968), A History of Muslim Historiography, Leiden: Brill.
-       Samaran, Charles (1961), L’Histoire et ses Méthodes, Gallimard.
-       Spalding, Roger; Christopher Parker (2007), Historiography: An Introduction, Manchester University Press.
-       Spuler, Bertold; et. al (1388 Š.), Tārīḵnigārī dar Īrān, translated by Yaqūb Āžānd, Tehran: Gostara.
-       Stanford, Michael (1994), A Companion to the Study of History, Blackwell.
-       Stanford Michael (1998), An Introduction to the Philosophy of History, Wiley-Blackwell.
Historical Perspective&Historiography
Volume 30, Issue 25
August 2020
Pages 99-121
Files
Share
How to cite
Statistics