Paradigmatic Ideas in the Critique of Historical Reason in Islam

Motevaly, Abdolah; HassanBeigi, Mohammad; Mosavi Siani, Saeid

doi:10.22051/hph.2019.18850.1191

Document Type : Scientific-Research

Authors

¹ Associate Professor of History, University of Arak

² Assistant Professor, Department of History, University of Arak

³ Ph.D. student, Shiraz University

https://doi.org/10.22051/hph.2019.18850.1191

Abstract

If we accept that any interpretation of the Islamic heritage of thought is based on a framework of ideas and concepts, which is the title of historical reason, then the continuation of the structure of this historical reason leads to the ineffectiveness of Muslim historical narratives in response to the problems of contemporary society.
Accordingly, how the epistemic breakdown of the ideas of the historical intellect was considered difficult in Islam, the article sought to answer it. It considers the article of narration and foundationalism as a theoretical framework that allows for such a break from the notions of historical reason in Islam; the theoretical sketches that can be called "paradigmatic ideas in the critique of historical reason in Islam".
Based on this paradigmatic conception of the foundations, while recognizing the metaphysical notions and the dichotomies that encircle the historical wisdom of Muslim historians, it provides historians with an alternative perspective on reading Islamic heritage. It also provides recognition of the structures of the historical intellect in Islam in the context of redefining the logic of historical thinking in Islam and modern narrative schemes. Relying on these new designs, Muslim historians can find a new reading of the Islamic tradition and thus find an answer to the daunting issues.

Keywords

References

- Abū Ziyd, N.Ḥ. 2008. Matn wa Maʻnāyi Matn az Nigāhi Ḥāmid Abū Ziyd. Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ……………… 2017. Nūsāzī, Taḥrīm wa Taʼwīl; az Shinākhti ʻIlmī tā Harās az Takfīr. M. Āramīdih. (Translator). Niy, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Aḥmadī, B. 2008. Risāliyih Tārīkh; Djustārī dar Hirminūtīki. Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ………….. 2009. Sākhtār wa Taʼwīli Matn. 11^th Ed. Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ………….. 2010. Mudirnītih wa Andīshiyih Intiḳādī, Tarhān. Markaz, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Al-Djābirī M.ʻĀ. 2008. ʻĀbid Al-Djābirī waʻAḳlānīyati Naḳādānih dar Tahāfat bar Falsafiyi Sharḳ. Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ………………... 2009. Naḳdi ʻAḳli ʻArabī. S.M. Āli Mahdī. (Translator). Nasli Āftāb, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Aman Khānī, ʻĪ. 2016. Nigāhī Intiḳādī bi Pazhūhishhāyi Shālūdih Shikanānih dar Īrān. Naḳdi Adabī, 9(34): 63-90. (In Persian) (Journal)

- Arkoun, M. 2013. Tārīkhmandīyi Andīshiyi Islāmī. R. Ḥamdāwī. (Translator). Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ………….. 2013. Dānishi Islāmī: Ḳirāʼatī bar Mabnāyi ʻUlūmi Insānī. ʻA. Sawārī. (Translator). Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- …………... 2008. Muḥammad Arkoun wa Mīrāthi Guftmānīyi Djahāni Waṭan. M.R. Waṣfī. (Editor). Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- …………... (n.d). Az Idjtihād bi Naḳdi ʻAḳli Islāmī. M. Khaladjī. (Translator). Tawānā Online Institute, (n.p). (In Persian) (Book)

- Carr, E.H. 2008. Tārīkh Čīst? Ḥ. Kāmshād. (Translator). Khārazmī, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Fludernik, M. 2012. Bisūyi Taʻrīfi Riwāyat wa Riwāyatgarī. 1^st Ed. Liḳāʼ al-Nūr, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Ḥasan Bagī, ʻA. 2017. ʻĀsīb Shināsīyi Naḳd wa Taḥlīli Tārīkh bā Taʼkīd bar Tārīkhi Islām. Arāk University, Arāk. (In Persian) (Book)

- Īmān, M.T 2011. Mabānīyi Pārādāymīyi Rawishhāyi Kamī wa Kiyfī dar ʻUlūmi Insānī. Research Institute of Hawzah & University, Qum. (In Persian) (Book)

- Lambton, M.C. 2010. Sākhtāri Riwāyat. J. Roberts. (Editor).Imām Ṣādiḳ University, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Maʻmūrī, ʻĀ. 2013. Taḥlīli Sākhti Riwāyat dar Ḳurān; Barrisīyi Manṭiḳi Tawālīyi Piyrafthā. Nigāhi Muʻāṣir, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Munslow, A. 2015. Wāsākhti Tārīkh. M. Mārdī Sidih. (Translator). Research Center for Islamic History, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Prince, G. 2012. Riwāyat Shināsī; Shikl wa Kārkirdi Riwāyat. M. Shahbā. (Translator). Mīnūyi Khirad, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Ṣāfī Pīrlūdjih, Ḥ. 2015. Darāmadī bar Taḥlīli Intiḳādīyi Guftimāni Riwāī. Niy, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Sherratt, Y. 2013. Falsafiyi ʻUlūmi Idjtimāʻīyi Ḳāriī; Hirminūtīk, Tabār Shināsīyi wa Naẓarīyih Intiḳādī az Yūnāni Bāstān tā Ḳarni Bīstu Yikum. H. Djalālī. (Translator). Niy, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Ṣīāmīyān Gurdjī, Z. & S. Mūsawī Sīyānī. 2015. Ḍarūrati Taʻāmuli Biyni Rishtiīyi Maʻrifat Shināsī wa ʻIlmi Tārīkhi Barāyi Ḥali Čālishhāyi Shakākānih Darbāriyi Imkān wa Iʻtibāri Shinākhti Tārīkhī. Muṭāliāti Mīyān Rishtihī dar ʻUlūmi Insānī, 7(3): 1-26. (In Persian) (Journal)

- Ṣīāmīyān Gurdjī, Z. 2015. Īdihī Rawish Shināsānih Barāyi Bāzyābīyi Ṭarḥwārihyi Tafsīrīyi Muwarikhāni Ḳurūni Nukhustni Islāmī. Pazhūhish Nāmiyi Tārīkhi Islām, 5(20): 5-24. (In Persian) (Journal)

- Stanford, M. 2007. Darāmadī bar Tārīkh Pazhūhī. 3^rd Ed. M. Ṣādīḳī. (Translator). SAMT & Imām Ṣādiḳ University, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- ……………. 2008. Darāmadī bar Falsafiyi Tārīkh. 3^rd Ed. A. Gul Muḥammadī. (Translator). SAMT & Imām Ṣādiḳ University, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Tanhāī, Ḥ.A. 2008. Djāmiʻih Shināsīyi Naẓarī; ʻUṣūl wa Mafāhīm. Bahmani Burnā, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Wāiẓī, A. 2015. Naḳdi Taḳrīri Naṣri Ḥāmid Abū Ziyd az Tārīkhmandīyi Ḳurān. Ḳurān Shinākht, 3(2): 41-65. (In Persian) (Journal)

- Wallace, M. 2015. Naẓarīyihāyi Riwāyat. M. Shahbā. (Translator). Hirmis, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Webster, R. 2011. Zhāk Dirīdā wa Wāsāzīyi Matn.ʻA. Bārānī. (Translator). Arghanūn, 1(4). (In Persian) (Journal)

- White, H. 2010. Matni Tārīkhī bi Muthābihi Farāwardiyi Adabī. J. Roberts. (Editor). Imām Ṣādiḳ University, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

-Wittgenstein, L. 2011. Dar Bābi Yaḳīn. M. Ḥusiynī. (Translator). Hirmis, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

- Munslow, A. 2000. The Routledge Companion to Historical Study. Routledge,Londan and New York. (In English) (Book)

- Ẓamīrān, M. 2015. Zhāk Dirīdā wa Mitāfīzīki Ḥuḍūr. Hirmis, Tehran. (In Persian) (Book)

Historical Perspective&Historiography

Paradigmatic Ideas in the Critique of Historical Reason in Islam

References

References

Volume 28, Issue 21 - Serial Number 106
May 2018
Pages 107-129

Paradigmatic Ideas in the Critique of Historical Reason in Islam

References

References

Volume 28, Issue 21 - Serial Number 106May 2018Pages 107-129

Volume 28, Issue 21 - Serial Number 106
May 2018
Pages 107-129