Document Type : Scientific-Research

Authors

1 Assistant Professor in History ,Research Institute of Imam Khomeini and Islamic Revolution

2 PhD candidate in the history of Islamic Revolution, Research Institute of Imam Khomeini and Islamic Revolution

Abstract

The Persian journals published in different arenas of science, in printed and electronic versions, follow some special rules and regulations. While the rules for writing and publishing the articles in the Iranian scientific journals are similar in structure, regulations are also different from journal to journal. Then this has caused the absence of standardization in journals. Although the rules regulated by the commission of supervising the journals of the ministry of science, research and technology has organized the publish of the scientific journals, these rules are minimal and experimental, and yet far from the international standards of the scientific journals. The international publishing standard is already regulated and produced by the international institute of ISO, and journals are to be published applying the international standards. The need for applying the world standards in Persian journals has caused the fields such as medicine and librarianship take this into their consideration but in the field of History this is yet lacked, and scientifically dubious.
However, the main concern in the present study is to examine the extent to which the international publishing standards of ISO are applied in the research and scientific journals of history. And we also want to examine if the insisted elements of the ISO publishing institute such as title page, list of the content, the repeated titles, footnotes, abstracts, the first page of the articles in a journal, the applied reference method are obeying the ISO standards. Since the present study is a practical one, and in the area of science survey, the approach we have applied in it is descriptive. In this study, taking the international publishing standards into consideration, we have recognized 26 research and science journals in the field of history, and set a chart for the criteria applied in the examination. The findings show that the research and scientific journals of history match the international publishing standards of ISO in 55 cases (69.47%).
Also the findings show that the journals apply the regulations and rules ratified by the ministry of science, research and technology, more than the international ISO publishing standards. Consequently, we recommend that: the international publishing standards should be ratified as the regulations of the ministry of science, research and technology, and enforced by the journals, so that the standardization may occur.

Keywords

List of sources with English handwriting
- Īzadī, ʿabd al-Reżā; Amīrpūr, zamīne. 2014. Raʿāyate estāndārdhāye našre moʾasseseye beyn al-melālīye īzo dar našrīyehāye fārsīye ketābdārī va eṭṭelāʿresānī, moṭāleʿāte mellīye ketābdārī va sāzmāndehīye eṭṭelāʿāt. (3)25: 93-109.
- Dayyānī, Moḥammad Ḥoseyn va Šahlā Šīrdel, 2007. Barrasī va moqāyeseye čekīdeye fārsīye maǰallehāye ʿelmī-pažūhešīye ḥowzeye ʿolūme ensānī bā estāndārde īzo 214. quarterly ketābdārī va eṭṭelāʿresānī. (2)2: 37-53.
- Dayyānī, Moḥammad Ḥoseyn, 1999. "ḥaǰme nemūne dar pažūhešhāye peymāyešī". Ketābdārī and eṭṭelāʿresānī, quarterly ketābḵāneye markazī va markaze asnāde āstāne qodse rażavī. (3)7: 59-71.
- Gīlvarī, ʿabbās va dīgarān, 2011. Mīzāne hamḵānīye našrīyehāye ʿelmī pažūhešī fārsīye kešāvarzī bā estāndārdhāye našre moʾasseseye beyn al-melalīye īzo. Pažūhešnāmeye pardāzeš va modīrīyate eṭṭelāʿāt: vīženāmeye ʿelmsanǰī. (2)66:5-27.
- Gīlvarī, ʿabbās, 1995. Barrasīye mīzāne hamḵānīye našrīyāte fārsī bā estāndārde īzo. Thesis kāršenāsīye aršad. Dānešgāhe ʿolūm pezeškīye Īrān: Tehrān.
- Moḵtārī, Vḥīd, 2003. enṭebāqe čekīdeye maqālehāye našrīyehāye dānešgāhhāye ʿolūme pezeškī and dastūr al-ʿamale gorūhe Vankūver and estāndārde īzo 214. Thesis kāršenāsīye aršad. Dānešgāhe ʿolūm pezeškīye Īrān: Tehrān.
- Hāšemī, Samīrā, 2011. Barrasīye mīzāne hamḵānīye našrīyehhāye dastresīye āzāde beyn al-melalīye ketābdārī bā estāndārdhāye īzo. Thesis kāršenāsīye aršad, dānešgāhe āzāde eslāmī, vāḥede ʿolūm va taḥqīqāt, Tehrān.
Iso 18. 1981.Content list of periodicals. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 214.1976. Abstract for Publications and Documentation. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 215.1986. Presentation of contributions to periodicals and other serials. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 30. 1966.Bibliographical strips. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 3297.1986. International Standard serial Number (ISSN). Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rded.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 5122. 1979.Abstract sheets in serial publications. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 6357.1985. Spine titles on books and other publication. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 690.1987. Bibliographic references _ Content, forms and Structure. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 7275.1985. Presentation of title information series. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information. (3rd ed.) Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 8.1977. Presentation of periodicals. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 9115.1987. Bibliographic identification of contributions in serials and books. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information. (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 9115.1987. Bibliographic identification of contributions in serials and books. Iso Standards Handbook 1: Documentation and information. (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Iso 999.1975. Index of a Publication. Iso International s Handbook 1: Documentation and information (3rd ed.). Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization.
Kovendi, D.1975.The presentation of socumentation, library, and archives. Journals and the ISO Standards. Unesco Bulletin for Libraries, 29 (4).
Lopez-Cozar, E. D.1999. ISO standards for the presentation of scientific periodicals: Little known and little used by Spanish biomedical journals. Journal of Documentation, 55 (3).
Lopez-Cozar, E. D., & Perez, R. R.1995.A model for assessing compliance of scientific journals with international standards. Libri, 45 (3-4).
Sho, N., and H. Sasaki. 1980.Biblid, bibliographic identification of serial publication. Dokumenteshon kenkya 30 (10).
Singh, S., & Singh, S.1990.Library and Information Science Periodicals in India: a study towards standardization. Herald of library science, 29 (3-4).